数论函数方程$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $的可解性

高丽,  李欣欣

高丽, 李欣欣. 数论函数方程$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $的可解性 [J]. 首都师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2026, 47(2): 38-45. DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2026.02.006
引用本文: 高丽, 李欣欣. 数论函数方程$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $的可解性 [J]. 首都师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2026, 47(2): 38-45. DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2026.02.006
GAO Li, LI Xinxin. The solvability of arithmetic function equation $ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $ [J]. Journal of Capital Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2026, 47(2): 38-45. DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2026.02.006
Citation: GAO Li, LI Xinxin. The solvability of arithmetic function equation $ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $ [J]. Journal of Capital Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2026, 47(2): 38-45. DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2026.02.006

数论函数方程$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $的可解性

DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2026.02.006
基金项目: 

国家自然科学基金项目 11471007.

详细信息
    通讯作者:

    李欣欣, 1148133417@qq.com.

  • 中图分类号: O156

The solvability of arithmetic function equation $ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $ $ (e=\left.12\right) $

  • 摘要:

    利用推广的广义Euler函数和Smarandache LCM函数的定义与性质,讨论包含广义Euler函数方程$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $在$ e=12 $时整数解问题。

     

    Abstract:

    Using definition and properties of the generalized Euler function and Smarandache LCM function, this paper discusses the integer solutions problems of equations involving generalized Euler functions $ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)(e=12) $.

     

  • 数论函数方程求解问题一直是数论的重要研究领域。广义Euler函数$ {\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right) $定义为序列1, 2, $ \cdots $, $ \left[\frac{n}{e}\right] $中与$ n $互素的数的个数,其中$ \left[\frac{n}{e}\right] $表示对$ \frac{n}{e} $进行取整,是Euler函数$ \varphi \left(n\right) $的推广[1]。Smarandache LCM函数$ SL\left(n\right) $的定义为最小正整数$ m $, 使得$ \mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , m $的最小公倍数能被$ n $整除[2], 即$ SL\left(n\right)=\min\{m:m\in {Z}^{+}, n|[\mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , m]\} $,其中$ [\mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , m] $表示$ \mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , m $的最小公倍数。伪Smarandache函数$ Z\left(n\right) $定义为$ Z\left(n\right)=\min\left\{m:m\in {Z}^{+}, n\left|\frac{m(m+1)}{2}\right.\right\} $, 其中$ {Z}^{+} $是正整数集合[3]。文献[4-8]讨论了包含广义Euler函数方程$ SL\left(n\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right) $、$ {\varphi }_{2}\left(n\right)=S\left(SL\right({n}^{k}\left)\right) $、$ S\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right) $、$ S\left(SL\right({n}^{2}\left)\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right) $以及$ S\left(n\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $的可解性; 文献[9-11]讨论了数论函数方程$ Z\left({n}^{k}\right)=\varphi \left({n}^{2}\right) $、$ Z\left({n}^{k}\right)=\varphi \left({n}^{k}\right) $、$ k{\varphi }_{2}\left(n\right(n+1\left)\right)+\varphi \left(n\right)=2S\left(SL\right({n}^{11}\left)\right) $和$ Z\left(n\right)={\varphi }_{2}\left(n\right) $的可解性; 文献[12-15]讨论了包含广义Euler复合函数方程$ Z\left({n}^{2}\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $、$ Z\left({n}^{2}\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(SL\right({n}^{2}\left)\right) $、$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)={\varphi }_{e}^{2}\left(n\right) $以及$ Z\left(n\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $的可解性; 文献[16]讨论了数论函数方程

    $$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)={\varphi }_{e}\left(n\right)(e=8) $$ (1)

    的可解性。在现有文献研究基础上,本文做了更进一步的改进,考虑当$ e=12 $时的情况,得出如下结论。

    定理  数论函数方程

    $$ {\varphi }_{12}\left(n\right)=Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right) $$ (2)

    的所有正整数解为$ n=360 $,$ {3}^{\beta }\times 19 $,$ {3}^{{\beta }_{1}}\times 38 $,$ 13{p}_{1} $,$ 21{p}_{2} $,$ 26{p}_{3} $,$ 28{p}_{4} $,$ 36{p}_{5} $,$ 42{p}_{6} $,其中$ \beta \ge 3 $且为奇数,$ {\beta }_{1}\ge 4 $且为偶数,$ {p}_{1}\ge 17 $,$ {p}_{2}\ge 11 $,$ {p}_{3}\ge 17 $,$ {p}_{4}\ge 11 $,$ {p}_{5}\ge 11 $,$ {p}_{6}\ge 11 $,且所有$ {p}_{i}(1\le i\le 6) $均为奇素数。

    本文记$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为$ n $的素因子个数且可重复计数; $ \omega \left(n\right) $为$ n $的不同的素因子个数,$ \varOmega \left(1\right)=\omega \left(1\right)=0 $。

    引理1[17]  当$ n\ge 3 $时,$ \varphi \left(n\right) $为偶数。

    引理2[18]  若$ n={p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}{p}_{2}^{{\alpha }_{2}}\cdots {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $是$ n $的标准分解式,则$ \varphi \left(n\right)=\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k}{p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}-1}({p}_{i}-1) $,其中$ {\alpha }_{i}\ge 1 $。

    引理3[18]  对任意素数$ p\ge 3 $,$ k\in \mathbf{N} $,$ Z\left({p}^{k}\right)={p}^{k}-1 $。当$ p=2 $时,有$ Z\left({2}^{k}\right)={2}^{k+1}-1 $。

    引理4[19]  若$ n={p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}{p}_{2}^{{\alpha }_{2}}\cdots {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,其中$ {p}_{1} , {p}_{2} , \cdots , {p}_{k} $为互异的素数,则$ SL\left(n\right)=\max\left\{{p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}}\left|i=\mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , k\right.\right\} $,$ {\alpha }_{i}\ge 1 $。当$ p $为素数且$ k\ge 1 $时,$ SL\left({p}^{k}\right)={p}^{k} $。

    引理5[20]  若$ n={2}^{\alpha } $,$ \alpha > 0 $,则

    $$ {\varphi }_{8}\left(n\right)=\left\{\begin{array}{ll}0, & \begin{array}{c}\alpha =\mathrm{1, 2};\end{array}\\ 1, & \alpha =3;\\ {2}^{\alpha -4}, & \alpha \ge 4。\end{array}\right. $$

    引理6[20]  若$ n={2}^{\alpha }\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k}{p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}} > 8 $,其中$ {p}_{i}(1\le i\le k) $是不同的奇素数。记$ {P}_{k}=\left\{{p}_{1}, {p}_{2}, \cdots , {p}_{k}\right\} $,$ {R}_{{P}_{k}}= \left\{{r}_{i}\left|{p}_{i}\equiv {r}_{i}\left(\text{mod}8\right), 0\le {r}_{i}\le 7, {p}_{i}\in {P}_{k}, 1\le i\le k\right.\right\} $,则

    $$ {\varphi }_{8}\left(n\right)=\left\{\begin{array}{l}\frac{1}{8}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{4}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\alpha }, \begin{array}{c}\alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, {R}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 7}\right\}, \left\{5\right\};\end{array}\\ \begin{array}{c}\frac{1}{8}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{8}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)-\left[\frac{\alpha +1}{2}\right]}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\frac{1}{2}(1-{(-1)}^{\alpha })}, \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}, 2\right\}, {R}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{3, 7}\right\}, \left\{3\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{8}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{8}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)-\left[\frac{\alpha }{2}\right]}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\frac{1}{2}(1-{(-1)}^{\alpha })}+\frac{1-\left[\frac{\alpha +1}{2}\right]}{4}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)}, \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}, 2\right\}, {R}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{7\right\};\\ \frac{1}{8}\varphi \left(n\right), \text{其他}。\end{array}\right. $$

    引理7[20]  若$ n={2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\ge 12 $,则

    $$ {\varphi }_{12}\left(n\right)=\left\{\begin{array}{l}\frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)-\frac{1}{2}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}, \begin{array}{c}\alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\};\end{array}\\ \begin{array}{c}\frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{3}(-1){}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}, \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right), \text{其他}。\end{array}\right. $$

    引理8[20]  若$ n={2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k}{p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}} > 12 $,其中$ {p}_{i}(1\le i\le k) $是不同的奇素数且$ \text{gcd}({p}_{i}, 6)=1 $,$ 1\le i\le k $。记$ {P}_{k}=\left\{{p}_{1}, {p}_{2}, \cdots , {p}_{k}\right\} $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{{r}_{i}\left|{p}_{i}\equiv {r}_{i}\left(\text{mod12}\right), \right.\right. $ $ 0\le \left.{r}_{i}\le 11, {p}_{i}\in {P}_{k}, 1\le i\le k\right\} $,则

    $$ {\varphi }_{12}\left(n\right)=\left\{\begin{array}{l}\frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{4}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\alpha }, \begin{array}{c}\alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, \beta =0, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\}, \left\{7\right\};\end{array}\\ \begin{array}{c}\frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{4}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\alpha }, \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, \beta \ge 2, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\}, \left\{7\right\}, \left\{11\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{6}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+\left[\frac{\alpha +1}{2}\right]}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\left[\frac{\alpha +1}{2}\right]-\beta }, \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}, 2\right\}, \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\}, \\ \begin{array}{c}\end{array}\begin{array}{c}\end{array}\begin{array}{c}\end{array}\begin{array}{c}\end{array}\begin{array}{c}\end{array}\begin{array}{c}\end{array}\text{或}\alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, \beta =1, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\}, \text{或}\alpha =2, \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\};\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{6}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-\beta }, \alpha \ge 3, \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\}, \begin{array}{c}R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\}, \left\{11\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{5}{12}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)}, \alpha =0, \beta =0, \begin{array}{c}R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right)+\frac{1}{12}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{\omega \left(n\right)-1}, \alpha =1, \beta =0, \begin{array}{c}R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\};\end{array}\\ \frac{1}{12}\varphi \left(n\right), \text{其他}。\end{array}\right. $$

    $ n\le 12 $时,方程(2)无解,以下讨论$ n > 12 $时解的情况。

    情况1  设$ n={2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta } > 12 $,$ \alpha \ge 0 $,$ \beta \ge 0 $。由引理4知$ SL\left(n\right)=\max\left\{{2}^{\alpha }, {3}^{\beta }\right\} $。

    情况1.1  若$ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,则$ \beta \ge 2 $,$ \varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }\right)=1 $。设$ SL\left(n\right)={3}^{\beta } $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({3}^{\beta }\right)={3}^{\beta }-1 $,从而由引理2和7可得式(2)为

    $$ {3}^{\beta -2}-{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}=2({3}^{\beta }-1) \text{,} $$

    此时$ {3}^{\beta -2}-{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)} < 2({3}^{\beta }-1) $,矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况1.2  若$ \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,则$ \alpha \ge 3 $,$ \varphi \left({3}^{\beta }\right)\le 2 $。设$ SL\left(n\right)={2}^{\alpha } $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({2}^{\alpha }\right)={2}^{\alpha +1}-1 $,从而由引理2和7可得式(2)为

    $$ {2}^{\alpha -3}\varphi \left({3}^{\beta }\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}=3({2}^{\alpha +1}-1)\le {2}^{\alpha -2}+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)} \text{,} $$

    此时$ 3({2}^{\alpha +1}-1) > {2}^{\alpha -2}+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)} $矛盾,方程无解。

    情况1.3  若$ \alpha \ge 2 $且$ \beta \ge 2 $。

    情况1.3.1  设$ SL\left(n\right)={2}^{\alpha } $,则$ \alpha \ge 4 $。由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({2}^{\alpha }\right)={2}^{\alpha +1}-1 $,从而由引理2和7可得式(2)为

    $$ {2}^{\alpha -2}\cdot {3}^{\beta -2}={2}^{\alpha +1}-1 \text{,} $$

    等式两边的奇偶性不同,矛盾,此时方程(2)无解。

    情况1.3.2  设$ SL\left(n\right)={3}^{\beta } $,则$ \beta \ge 2 $。由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({3}^{\beta }\right)={3}^{\beta }-1 $,从而由引理2和7可得式(2)为

    $$ {2}^{\alpha -2}\cdot {3}^{\beta -2}={3}^{\beta }-1 \text{,} $$

    根据等式两边的3的个数可知$ \beta =2 $,则$ \alpha =5 $,此时$ SL\left(n\right)={2}^{5}\ne {3}^{2} $,矛盾,此时方程(2)无解。

    情况2  设$ n={2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k}{p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}} > 12 $,其中$ \alpha \ge 0 $,$ \beta \ge 0 $,$ k\ge 1 $,$ {\alpha }_{i}\ge 1 $,$ {p}_{i} $是不同的奇素数,$ 1\le i\le k $,并且$ \text{gcd}({p}_{i}, 6)=1 $,记$ {P}_{k}=\left\{{p}_{1}, {p}_{2}, \cdots , {p}_{k}\right\} $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{{r}_{i}\left|{p}_{i}\equiv {r}_{i}\left(\text{mod12}\right), 0\le {r}_{i}\le 11, {p}_{i}\in {P}_{k}, 1\le i\le k\right.\right\} $。令$ n={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}{m}_{k} $,且$ \text{gcd}({p}_{k}, {m}_{k})=1 $。由引理4知$ SL\left(n\right)=\max\left\{{2}^{\alpha }, {3}^{\beta }, {p}_{i}^{{\alpha }_{i}}\left|i=\mathrm{1, 2}, \cdots , k\right.\right\} $。

    情况2.1  若$ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ \beta =0 $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{7\right\} $。

    设$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$ (3)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})=3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k} \text{,} $$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|3\times {2}^{k}\right. $。又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{7\right\} $,所以$ {p}_{k}=7 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 1 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }\right)=1 $。故由式(3)有

    $$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 6-12=6{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\le -78 \text{,} $$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 11 $,$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 10 $。由式(3)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 12-12=6\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}=\\ \left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge -24{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} 。\end{array} $$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right) > 14 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 12-12=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} > 0 $,矛盾,所以$ 10\le \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\le 14 $。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数时有$ -24=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,因为$ 7\nmid 24 $,方程无解。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数时有$ 0=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,可得$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 19 $,$ 1\le i\le k-1 $,且所有$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{3} $。设$ {p}_{k-1}\ge 19 $,则有

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 18({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$

    且有

    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(3)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})= \\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{2}\times {2}^{3(k-2)-1} > 3\times {2}^{k} 。 \end{array}$$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.2  若$ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ \beta \ge 2 $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{7\right\} $,$ \left\{11\right\} $。

    情况2.2.1  设$ SL\left(n\right)={3}^{\beta } $,令$ n={3}^{\beta }{m}_{0} $,则$ \text{gcd}(3, {m}_{0})=1 $。由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({3}^{\beta }\right)={3}^{\beta }-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ 2\times {3}^{\beta -1}\varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)+3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+1}=12({3}^{\beta }-1) \text{,} $$ (4)

    从而有

    $$ 2\left({3}^{\beta -1}\varphi \right({m}_{0})-6({3}^{\beta }-1\left)\right)=3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}{2}^{k+1} 。 $$

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {p}_{1}\ge 7 $,$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 6 $。故由式(4)有

    $$\begin{array}{c} {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 12-12=2\times {3}^{\beta -1}\varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)-12\times {3}^{\beta }= \\ \left(2\varphi \right({m}_{0})-36)\cdot {3}^{\beta -1}\ge -8\times {3}^{\beta } \text{,} \end{array}$$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right) > 18 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 12-12=\left(2\varphi \right({m}_{0})-36)\cdot {3}^{\beta -1} > 0 $,矛盾,所以$ 6\le \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)\le 18 $。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数时有$ 0=\left(2\varphi \right({m}_{0})-36)\cdot {3}^{\beta -1} $,可得$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=18 $,从而$ {m}_{0}=19 $,27,38,54。又因为$ \text{gcd}(3, {m}_{0})=1 $,故$ {m}_{0}=19 $,38,所以$ n=19\times {3}^{\beta } $ $ (\beta \ge 3 $且为奇数),$ {3}^{{\beta }_{1}}\times 38({\beta }_{1}\ge 4 $且为偶数),经检验均为方程(2)的解。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数时有$ -24=\left(2\varphi \right({m}_{0})-36)\cdot {3}^{\beta -1} $,由等式两边3的个数可知$ \beta =2 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,则必有$ \beta \ge 3 $,$ {p}_{i}\ge 7 $,那么至少存在1个$ {p}_{i}\ge 11 $,$ 1\le i\le 2 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=\varphi ({2}^{\alpha }\cdot {p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}{p}_{2}^{{\alpha }_{2}})\ge 60 $。故由式(4)有

    $$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 24-12=2\times {3}^{\beta -1}\varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)-12\times {3}^{\beta }=\left(2\varphi \right({m}_{0})-36)\cdot {3}^{\beta -1}\ge 28\times {3}^{\beta } 。 $$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,则$ \beta \ge 3 $,那么至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 19 $,$ 1\le i\le k $,同时所有$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{2} $。不妨设$ {p}_{k}\ge 19 $,则有

    $$ 2({p}_{k}-1)\ge 36 \text{,} $$

    且有

    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-1}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{2(k-1)}-1 > {2}^{2(k-1)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(4)有

    $$\begin{array}{c} 3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}{2}^{k+1}-12={3}^{\beta -1}\left(2\right.\varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)-36)\ge \\ {3}^{\beta -1}\left(36\right.\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-1}({p}_{i}-1)-36)=4\times {3}^{\beta +1}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-1}({p}_{i}-1)- \\ 1) > {2}^{2}\times {2}^{4}\times {2}^{2(k-1)-1} > 3\times {2}^{k+1} 。\end{array} $$

    矛盾,此时方程(2)无解。

    情况2.2.2  若$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,利用引理3可得$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+1}=\\ 12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} \end{array} $$ (5)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})= 3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}{2}^{k+1} \text{,}$$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|3\times {2}^{k+1}\right. $,又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{7, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{7\right\} $,$ \left\{11\right\} $,所以$ {p}_{k}=7 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 2 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\right)\ge 6 $。故由式(5)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 12-12= 6\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}= \\ \left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}\ge -48{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} \text{,} \end{array}$$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right) > 14 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 12-12=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} > 0 $,显然矛盾,所以$ 6\le \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\le 14 $。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数时有$ 0=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} $,可得$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,此时方程(2)无解。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数,则$ -24=\left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} $,因为$ 7\nmid 24 $,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,必有$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 11 $,可得$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 60 $。由式(5)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 24-12=6\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}= \\ \left(6\varphi \right({m}_{k})-84){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge 276{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} 。\end{array} $$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 19 $,$ 1\le i\le k-1 $,且所有$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{3} $。设$ {p}_{k-1}\ge 19 $,则有

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 18({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$

    且有

    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(5)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}3\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}{2}^{k+1}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})= \\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{2}\times {2}^{3(k-2)-1} > 3\times {2}^{k+1} 。 \end{array}$$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.3  若$ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}, 2\right\} $,$ \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{5\right\} $,或$ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ \beta =1 $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $,或$ \alpha =2 $,$ \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $。

    情况2.3.1  根据定理2中情况2.3的题设可得

    $$ \left\{\begin{array}{l}\alpha =0, \beta =0, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\};\\ \alpha =0, \beta =1, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\}, \left\{11\right\}。\end{array}\right. $$ (6)

    设$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k+1}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$ (7)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})={(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+1} \text{,} $$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|{2}^{k+1}\right. $,又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}} $的值满足式(6),所以$ {p}_{k}=5 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 1 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\right)\le 2 $。故由式(7)有

    $$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 4-12= 4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\le -52 \text{,} $$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    若$ k=2 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 11 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 10 $。故由式(7)有

    $$\begin{array}{c} {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 8-12= 4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}=\\ \left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge -20{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} 。 \end{array}$$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\ge 15 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 8-12=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge 0 $,矛盾,则有$ 10\le \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\le 14 $。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数则$ -20=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,比较等式两边5的幂次可知$ {\alpha }_{k}=2 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,方程(2)无解。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数则有$ -4=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,因为$ 5\nmid 4 $,此时方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,则有$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 17 $,其中$ 1\le i\le k-1 $,且$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{3} $。设$ {p}_{k-1}\ge 17 $,则有

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 16({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$
    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(7)有

    $$\begin{array}{c} {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+1}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})= \\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{2}\times {2}^{3(k-2)-1} > {2}^{k+1} 。\end{array} $$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.3.2  根据定理2中情况2.3的题设可得

    $$ \left\{\begin{array}{l}\alpha =1, \beta =0, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\};\\ \alpha =2, \beta =0, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\}, \left\{11\right\};\\ \alpha \in \left\{\mathrm{1, 2}\right\}, \beta =1, R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\}, \left\{5\right\}, \left\{11\right\}。\end{array}\right. $$ (8)

    设$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+1}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$ (9)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})={(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}{2}^{k+1} \text{,} $$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|{2}^{k+1}\right. $,又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}} $的值满足式(8),所以$ {p}_{k}=5 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 1 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\right)\le 4 $。故由式(9)有

    $$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 4-12=4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\le -44 \text{,} $$

    矛盾,此时方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 11 $,从而有$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 10 $。利用式(9)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 8-12=4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}= \\ \left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge -20{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} 。\end{array} $$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\ge 15 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\times 8-12=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge 0 $,矛盾,则$ 10\le \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\le 14 $。当$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数, 有$ -4=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,因为$ 5\nmid 4 $,此时方程(2)无解。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数, 则$ -20=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} $,比较等式两边5的幂次可知$ {\alpha }_{k}=2 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,此时方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 17 $,其中$ 1\le i\le k-1 $且$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{3} $。设$ {p}_{k-1}\ge 17 $,则有

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 16({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$
    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(9)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+2}\cdot {2}^{k+1}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})= \\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{2}\times {2}^{3(k-2)-1} > {2}^{k+1} 。 \end{array}$$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.4  若$ \alpha \ge 3 $,$ \beta \in \left\{\mathrm{0, 1}\right\} $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{5\right\} $,$ \left\{11\right\} $。

    情况2.4.1  若$ SL\left(n\right)={2}^{\alpha } $,不妨设$ n={2}^{\alpha }m $,则有$ \text{gcd}(2, m) $ $ =1 $。利用引理3得$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({2}^{\alpha }\right)={2}^{\alpha +1}-1 $,由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {2}^{\alpha -3}\varphi \left(m\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k}=3({2}^{\alpha +1}-1) \text{,} $$

    因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{5\right\} $,$ \left\{11\right\} $,故利用引理1可得$ \varphi \left(m\right) $为$ \ge 4 $的偶数。等式两边奇偶性不同,矛盾,此时方程(2)无解。

    情况2.4.2  设$ SL\left(n\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3知$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)= $ $ Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k+2}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$ (10)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})={(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k+2} \text{,} $$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|{2}^{k+2}\right. $,又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{\mathrm{5, 11}\right\} $,$ \left\{5\right\} $,$ \left\{11\right\} $,所以$ {p}_{k}=5 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 2 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\right)\ge 4 $。故由式(10)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 8-12= 4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}=\\ \left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}\ge -44{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} \text{,}\end{array} $$

    当$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\ge 15 $时,$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 8-12=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}\ge 0 $,矛盾,则$ 4\le \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)\le 14 $。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为偶数, $ -20=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} $,比较等式两边5的幂次可知$ {\alpha }_{1}=2 $,则有$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=14 $,不是Euler商数,此时方程(2)无解。若$ \varOmega \left(n\right) $为奇数, $ -4=\left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1} $,因为$ 5\nmid 4 $,此时方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,则$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 11 $,可得$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 40 $。利用式(10)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 16-12=4\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}=\\ \left(4\varphi \right({m}_{k})-60){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge 100{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} 。 \end{array}$$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,必有$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,则至少存在$ k-2 $个$ {p}_{i}\ge 17 $,$ 1\le i\le k-1 $,且所有$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{3} $。设$ {p}_{k-1}\ge 17 $,则有

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 16({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$

    且有

    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{3(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(10)有

    $$\begin{array}{c} {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\cdot {2}^{k+2}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})=\\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{2}\times {2}^{3(k-2)-1} > {2}^{k+2} 。\end{array} $$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.5  若$ \alpha =0 $,$ \beta =0 $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $。

    设$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+5\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$ (11)

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})=5\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k} \text{,} $$

    则有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|5\times {2}^{k}\right. $,又因为$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $,所以$ {p}_{k}=11 $。

    若$ k=1 $,则$ {\alpha }_{1}\ge 2 $,从而$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }\right)=1 $。故由式(11)有

    $$ {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 10-12=10{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}-1}-12{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}} < -122 \text{,} $$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k=2 $,必有$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{1}\ge 23 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=\varphi \left({2}^{\alpha }{3}^{\beta }{p}_{1}^{{\alpha }_{1}}\right)\ge 22 $。利用式(11)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}\times 20-12=10\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}-12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}=\\ \left(10\varphi \right({m}_{k})-132){p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\ge 88{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1} \text{,}\end{array} $$

    矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    若$ k\ge 3 $,必有$ {\alpha }_{k}\ge 2 $,$ {p}_{i}\ge 23 $,$ 1\le i\le k-1 $,且$ {p}_{i}-1 > {2}^{4} $,可得

    $$ ({p}_{k-1}-1)({p}_{k}-1)\ge 22({p}_{k}-1) > 12{p}_{k} \text{,} $$

    且有

    $$ \prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1 > {2}^{4(k-2)}-1 > {2}^{4(k-2)-1} \text{,} $$

    故由式(11)有

    $$ \begin{array}{c}5\times {(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k}-12={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(\right({p}_{k}-1\left)\varphi \right({m}_{k})- \\ 12{p}_{k}) > {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\left(12\right.{p}_{k}\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-12{p}_{k})=\\ 12{p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}(\prod \limits_{i=1}^{k-2}({p}_{i}-1)-1) > {2}^{3}\times {2}^{3}\times {2}^{4(k-2)-1} > 5\times {2}^{k} 。\end{array} $$

    矛盾,此时方程无解。

    情况2.6  若$ \alpha =1 $,$ \beta =0 $,$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $。

    设$ SL\left(n\right)={{p}_{k}}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)+{(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)}{2}^{k}=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$

    从而有

    $$ ({p}_{k}-1)\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}\varphi \right({m}_{k})-\frac{12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1)}{{p}_{k}-1})={(-1)}^{\varOmega \left(n\right)+1}{2}^{k} \text{,} $$

    于是就有$ {p}_{k}-1\left|{2}^{k}\right. $,又由$ R{\text{'}}_{{P}_{k}}=\left\{11\right\} $,这样的奇素数$ {p}_{k} $不存在,方程(2)无解。

    情况2.7  若

    $$ \left\{\begin{array}{l} \alpha \in\{0, 1\}, \beta=0, \text{且} R_{P_k}^{\prime} \text{中存在} r_i=1 \text{或} r_i=5 \text{且} r_j=7 ; ~ \\ \alpha \in\{0, 1\}, \beta=1, \text{且} R_{P_k}^{\prime} \text{中存在} r_i=1 \text{或} r_i=7 ; ~ \\ \alpha \geqslant 2, \beta \in\{0, 1\}, \text{且} R_{P_k}^{\prime} \text{中存在} r_i=1 \text{或} r_i=7 ; ~ \\ \alpha \in\{0, 1\}, \beta \geqslant 2, \text{且} R_{P_k}^{\prime} \text{中存在} r_i=1 \text{或} r_i=5 ; ~ \\ \alpha \geqslant 2 \text{且} \beta \geqslant 2 。 \end{array}\right. $$

    其中$ 0\le {r}_{i}\le 11 $,$ 0\le {r}_{j}\le 11 $,$ 1\le i\le k $,$ 1\le j\le k $。

    情况2.7.1  假设$ SL\left(n\right)={2}^{\alpha } $,必有$ \alpha \ge 3 $,记$ n={2}^{\alpha }m $,显然有$ \text{gcd}(2, m)=1 $。利用引理3可得$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({2}^{\alpha }\right)={2}^{\alpha +1}-1 $,再由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {2}^{\alpha -3}\varphi \left(m\right)=3({2}^{\alpha +1}-1) \text{,} $$

    因为$ \varphi \left(m\right) $为偶数,等式两边奇偶性不同,矛盾,方程(2)无解。

    情况2.7.2  设$ SL\left(n\right)={3}^{\beta } $,则$ \beta \ge 2 $,令$ n={3}^{\beta }{m}_{0} $,则$ \text{gcd}(3, {m}_{0})=1 $。由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)=Z\left({3}^{\beta }\right)={3}^{\beta }-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {3}^{\beta -2}\varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=2({3}^{\beta }-1) \text{,} $$

    比较等式两边的3的幂次可知$ \beta =2 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{0}\right)=16 $,于是有$ {m}_{0} $=17,32,34,40,48,60。又$ \text{gcd}(3, {m}_{0})=1 $,$ SL\left(n\right)={3}^{2} $,所以$ {m}_{0}=40 $,则$ n={3}^{2}\times 40=360 $,经检验是方程(2)的解。

    情况2.7.3  设$ SL\left(n\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}} $,由引理3有$ Z\left(SL\right(n\left)\right)= $ $ Z\left({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}\right)={p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1 $,从而由引理2和8可得式(2)为

    $$ {p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}-1}({p}_{k}-1)\varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=12({p}_{k}^{{\alpha }_{k}}-1) \text{,} $$

    根据等式两边的$ {p}_{k} $的个数可知$ {\alpha }_{k}=1 $,则$ \varphi \left({m}_{k}\right)=12 $,从而$ {m}_{k}=13 $,21,26,28,36,42,所以$ n=13{p}_{1}({p}_{1}\ge 17) $,$ 21{p}_{2}({p}_{2}\ge 11) $,$ 26{p}_{3}({p}_{3}\ge 17) $,$ 28{p}_{4}({p}_{4}\ge 11) $,$ 36{p}_{5}({p}_{5}\ge 11) $,$ 42{p}_{6}({p}_{6}\ge 11) $,其中所有$ {p}_{i}(1\le i\le 6) $均为奇素数,经检验均是方程(2)的解。定理证毕。

  • [1] APOSTOL T M. Introduction to analytic number theory[M]. New York: Spring verlag, 1976: 156-162.
    [2] SMARANDACHE F. Only problems, not solutions[M]. Chicago: Xiquan Publishing House, 1993: 179-186.
    [3] 周建华, 瞿云云, 朱山山, 等. 数论函数方程$t \varphi_2(n(n+ 1))=S\left(S L\left(n^{17}\right)\right)$的可解性[J]. 贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2022, 40(6): 33-37. DOI: 10.16614/j.gznuj.zrb.2022.06.004.

    ZHOU J H, QU Y Y, ZHU S S, et al. The solvability of the arithmetic function equation $t \varphi_2(n(n+ 1))=S\left(S L\left(n^{17}\right)\right)$[J]. Journal of Guizhou Normal University (Natural Sciences), 2022, 40(6): 33-37. doi: 10.16614/j.gznuj.zrb.2022.06.004
    [4] 杜珊, 廖群英, 王慧莉. 方程$S L(n)=\varphi_e(n)$的正整数解[J]. 四川师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2023, 46(1): 29-36. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2023.01.003.

    DU S, LIAO Q Y, WANG H L. The positive integral solutions for the equation $S L(n)=\varphi_e(n)$[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University (Natural Science), 2023, 46(1): 29-36. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2023.01.003
    [5] 张四保. 数论函数方程$\varphi_2(n)=S\left(S L\left(n^k\right)\right)$的可解性[J]. 西南大学学报(自然科学版), 2020, 42(4): 65-69. DOI: 10.13718/j.cnki.xdzk.2020.04.008.

    ZHANG S B. The solvability of arithmetic function equation $\varphi_2(n)=S\left(S L\left(n^k\right)\right)$[J]. Journal of Southwest University (Natural Science Edition), 2020, 42(4): 65-69. doi: 10.13718/j.cnki.xdzk.2020.04.008
    [6] 王慧莉, 廖群英, 杜珊. 方程$S(S L(n))=\varphi_e(n)(e=3, 4, 6)$的可解性[J]. 四川师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2021, 44(6): 752-761. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2021.06.005.

    WANG H L, LIAO Q Y, DU S. The solvability for the equations $S(S L(n))=\varphi_e(n)(e=3, 4, 6)$[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University (Natural Science), 2021, 44(6): 752-761. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2021.06.005
    [7] 王慧莉, 廖群英, 任磊. 方程$S\left(S L\left(n^2\right)\right)=\varphi_e(n)(e=3, 4, 6)$的可解性[J]. 四川师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2022, 45(5): 595-604. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2022.05.003.

    WANG H L, LIAO Q Y, REN L. The solvability for the equation $S\left(S L\left(n^2\right)\right)=\varphi_e(n)(e=3, 4, 6)$[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University (Natural Science), 2022, 45(5): 595-604. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2022.05.003
    [8] 姜莲霞, 张四保. 关于方程$ S(n)=\varphi_e(S L(n)) $的正整数解[J]. 科技通报, 2022, 38(11): 5-8. DOI: 10.13774/j.cnki.kjtb.2022.11.002.

    JIANG L X, ZHANG S B. The positive integer solutions of the equation $ S(n)=\varphi_e(S L(n)) $[J]. Bulletin of Science and Technology, 2022, 38(11): 5-8. doi: 10.13774/j.cnki.kjtb.2022.11.002
    [9] 赵祈芬, 高丽. 包含伪Smarandache函数与欧拉函数的两个方程[J]. 贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2017, 35(3): 55-58. DOI: 10.16614/j.cnki.issn1004-5570.2017.03.008.

    ZHAO Q F, GAO L. Two equations involving the pseudo-Smarandache function and Euler function[J]. Journal of Guizhou Normal University (Natural Sciences), 2017, 35(3): 55-58. doi: 10.16614/j.cnki.issn1004-5570.2017.03.008
    [10] 高丽. 数论函数方程$k \varphi_2(n(n+1))+\varphi(n)=2 S\left(S L\left(n^{11}\right)\right)$的可解性[J]. 贵州大学学报(自然科学版), 2025, 42(3): 20-25. DOI: 10.15958/j.cnki.gdxbzrb.2025.03.03.

    GAO L. The solvability of arithmetic function equation $k \varphi_2(n(n+1))+\varphi(n)=2 S\left(S L\left(n^{11}\right)\right)$[J]. Journal of Guizhou University (Natural Sciences), 2025, 42(3): 20-25. doi: 10.15958/j.cnki.gdxbzrb.2025.03.03
    [11] 赵祈芬, 高丽. 数论函数方程$Z(n)=\varphi_2(n)$的解[J]. 云南师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2018, 38(2): 34-37. DOI: 10.7699/j.ynnu.ns-2018-020.

    ZHAO Q F, GAO L. Solutions of arithmetic function equation $Z(n)=\varphi_2(n)$[J]. Journal of Yunnan Normal University (Natural Sciences Edition), 2018, 38(2): 34-37. doi: 10.7699/j.ynnu.ns-2018-020
    [12] 李改利, 高丽, 戴妍百, 等. 一类包含Smarandache LCM函数与广义欧拉函数的方程[J]. 湖北大学学报(自然科学版), 2023, 45(2): 181-187. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-2375.2022.00.068.

    LI G L, GAO L, DAI Y B, et al. Equations involving the Smarandache LCM function and generalized Euler function[J]. Journal of Hubei University (Natural Science), 2023, 45(2): 181-187. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1000-2375.2022.00.068
    [13] 高倩, 高丽, 梁晓艳. 包含Smarandache LCM函数的两个方程的正整数解[J]. 延安大学学报(自然科学版), 2020, 39(2): 8-11+14. DOI: 10.13876/J.cnki.ydnse.2020.02.008.

    GAO Q, GAO L, LIANG X Y. The positive integer solutions of two equations involving the Smarandache LCM function[J]. Journal of Yan'an University (Natural Science Edition), 2020, 39(2): 8-11+14. doi: 10.13876/J.cnki.ydnse.2020.02.008
    [14] 杨张媛, 赵西卿, 白继文. 两个数论函数方程解的探讨[J]. 江西科学, 2018, 36(4): 579-581. DOI: 10.13990/j.issn1001-3679.2018.04.010.

    YANG Z Y, ZHAO X Q, BAI J W. Solvability of two arithmetic function equations[J]. Jiangxi Science, 2018, 36(4): 579-581. doi: 10.13990/j.issn1001-3679.2018.04.010
    [15] 朱杰, 廖群英. 方程$Z(n)=\varphi_e(S L(n))$的可解性[J]. 数学进展, 2019, 48(5): 541-554. DOI: 10.11845/sxjz.2018064b.

    ZHU J, LIAO Q Y. The solvability of the equation $Z(n)=\varphi_e(S L(n))$[J]. Advances in Mathematics, 2019, 48(5): 541-554. doi: 10.11845/sxjz.2018064b
    [16] 高丽. 广义Euler函数$\varphi_e(n)=Z(S L(n))$的可解性[J]. 沈阳大学学报(自然科学版), 2025, 37(5): 437-444.

    GAO L. Solvability of arithmetic function eqution $\varphi_e(n)=Z(S L(n))$[J]. Journal of Shenyang University (Natural Science), 2025, 37(5): 437-444.
    [17] 姜莲霞, 张四保, 傅湧. 形如$k \varphi(n)=\varphi_2(n)+S\left(n^m\right)$的两个方程的可解性[J]. 首都师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2021, 42(6): 8-11+70. DOI: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2021.06.002.

    JIANG L X, ZHANG S B, FU Y. Solvabilities of two equations of the form $k \varphi(n)=\varphi_2(n)+S\left(n^m\right)$[J]. Journal of Capital Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2021, 42(6): 8-11+70. doi: 10.19789/j.1004-9398.2021.06.002
    [18] 梁晓艳, 高丽, 高倩. 数论函数方程$Z\left(n^2\right)=\varphi^2{ }_e(n)(e= 1, 2)$解的探讨[J]. 云南师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2020, 40(6): 35-38. DOI: 10.7699/j.ynnu.ns-2020-078.

    LIANG X Y, GAO L, GAO Q. Solvability of $Z\left(n^2\right)=\varphi^2{ }_e(n)(e= 1, 2)$ function equations[J]. Journal of Yunnan Normal University (Natural Sciences Edition), 2020, 40(6): 35-38. doi: 10.7699/j.ynnu.ns-2020-078
    [19] 朱山山, 瞿云云, 周建华, 等. 数论函数方程$t \varphi(n)+ \varphi_2(n)=S\left(S L\left(n^k\right)\right)$的正整数解[J]. 贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2023, 41(2): 80-85+120. DOI: 10.16614/j.gznuj.zrb.2023.02.011.

    ZHU S S, QU Y Y, ZHOU J H, at al. The positive integer solutions of arithmetic function equation $t \varphi(n)+ \varphi_2(n)=S\left(S L\left(n^k\right)\right)$[J]. Journal of Guizhou Normal University (Natural Sciences), 2023, 41(2): 80-85+120. doi: 10.16614/j.gznuj.zrb.2023.02.011
    [20] 余礼, 廖群英. 方程$\varphi_e(n)=2^{\omega(n)}(e=8, 12)$的正整数解[J]. 四川师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2022, 45(3): 330-339. DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2022.03.006.

    YU L, LIAO Q Y. The positive integer solutions for the equation $\varphi_e(n)=2^{\omega(n)}(e=8, 12)$[J]. Journal of Sichuan Normal University (Natural Science), 2022, 45(3): 330-339. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-8395.2022.03.006
WeChat 点击查看大图
出版历程
  • 收稿日期:  2024-11-20

目录

    /

    返回文章
    返回